BIM Clash Detection: Process, Benefits, Best Practices 2024

BIM clash detection is a game-changer for construction projects. Here's what you need to know:

• It uses 3D models to spot conflicts between building systems before construction starts
• Catches design issues early, saving time and money on-site
• Helps architects, engineers, and builders work together smoothly
• Deals with hard clashes (things bumping into each other), soft clashes (things too close for comfort), and time-based clashes (scheduling conflicts)

Key benefits:

• Cuts rework by up to 30% of project costs
• Slashes change orders by 42% on average
• Trims overall project costs by about 5%

Best practices for 2024:

1. Start clash detection from day one
2. Set clear communication rules
3. Hold regular team meetings
4. Use up-to-date software
5. Keep 3D models current

Top clash detection tools:

The future of clash detection:

• AI will speed up clash spotting and suggest fixes
• Automated systems will run tests on their own
• VR and AR will let teams explore and fix issues in 3D

Bottom line: BIM clash detection is becoming essential for smooth, efficient, and cost-effective construction projects.

How BIM clash detection works

BIM clash detection helps spot and fix design conflicts before construction starts. Here's how it works:

Creating 3D models

First, we build detailed 3D models of the project. This includes:

• Architectural plans
• Structural elements
• MEP systems (mechanical, electrical, plumbing)

We usually use software like Autodesk Revit for this. Then, we combine these models into a single "federated" model.

Setting clash rules

Next, we set up rules for what counts as a clash. This might include:

• How close objects can be before it's a problem
• Which building systems to check against each other
• Areas that need extra attention

Running clash tests

Now it's time to run the clash detection. We typically use software like Autodesk Navisworks for this.

The software scans the federated model, looking for intersections or close calls between different elements. It flags these as potential clashes.

Reviewing clash results

After the scan, we review the results. For each clash, we ask:

• Is it a real problem?
• How serious is it?
• Who needs to fix it?

We often sort clashes into categories:

Fixing clashes

Finally, we resolve the identified clashes. This usually involves:

1. Assigning clashes to the right team members
2. Discussing possible solutions
3. Updating the original 3D models
4. Re-running clash detection to check the fixes

We repeat this process until we've resolved all major clashes.

Advantages of BIM clash detection

BIM clash detection packs a punch for construction projects. Here's why:

Saving time and money

Spot design conflicts early, dodge costly on-site changes:

• Cuts rework by up to 30% of project costs
• Slashes change orders by 42% on average
• Trims overall project costs by about 5%

Take the Alder Hey Hospital Project in Liverpool. The team caught over 400 clashes before breaking ground. Result? Dodged major delays and extra costs.

Better project quality

Early clash detection means:

• Fewer construction errors
• Spot-on installations
• Top-notch end results

Don't just take our word for it. McGraw Hill Construction found 61% of BIM-using pros saw fewer project errors.

Improved teamwork

BIM clash detection boosts collaboration:

• One digital playground for all stakeholders
• Crystal-clear issue communication
• Faster decision-making

Less on-site headaches

Solve conflicts before construction kicks off:

• Fewer work stoppages
• Lower safety risks
• Less material waste

More accurate installations

BIM clash detection ups installation accuracy:

• Precise 3D modelling of building parts
• Detailed pre-fab work
• Less need for on-site tweaks

Case in point: Abu Dhabi International Airport's Midfield Terminal Building. Advanced BIM tools flagged thousands of potential conflicts early. The payoff? Smoother on-site installations.

Types of clashes in BIM

BIM clash detection spots three main clash types: hard, soft, and time-based. Each needs its own fix.

Hard clashes

Hard clashes happen when building parts overlap. They're easy to spot. Think:

• A duct cutting through a wall
• A pipe hitting a beam
• Electrical stuff tangled with HVAC

BIM software uses fancy math to find these. They're usually the first things fixed.

Soft clashes

Soft clashes (or clearance clashes) are when things are too close. They're trickier to spot but can cause big headaches. For example:

• Not enough room to fix an HVAC unit
• Electrical panels too close to other stuff
• Beams nearly touching ceiling lights

BIM software uses set rules to find these. Fixing them often takes more thought than hard clashes.

Time-based clashes

Time-based (or 4D) clashes mess with the project timeline. They can slow everything down. Like:

• Different crews trying to work in the same spot
• Materials showing up before the space is ready
• Equipment arriving too early

To spot these, teams mix the project schedule with the 3D model. It helps them see what might go wrong before it does.

Best practices for clash detection in 2024

BIM clash detection is crucial for spotting issues before they hit the building site. Here's how to make it work better:

Start early

Kick off clash detection from day one. It helps catch problems early. Autodesk found that 40% of building rework comes from design clashes. Starting early can slash this number.

Set clear communication rules

Good team chat is key. Set up a plan for clash discussions:

• Use a shared platform for clash notes
• Create a chain of command for clash decisions
• Agree on clash labeling and tracking

Hold regular meetings

Meet often to discuss clashes. Weekly catch-ups keep everyone in sync:

• Review new clashes
• Check progress on old ones
• Plan for tricky clashes

Use up-to-date software

Pick the right tools. Top choices in 2024:

Keep your software current for the latest clash-finding features.

Keep models updated

Fresh models mean fewer false alarms. Ensure everyone uses the latest version:

• Set update schedules
• Use cloud-based models for real-time changes
• Check model versions before each clash test

Clash detection tools

Common clash detection software

Several BIM tools offer clash detection. Here's a look at some popular options:

Navisworks combines 3D models from various disciplines. You can set up clash tests, generate reports, and assign issues to team members.

Solibri Model Checker goes beyond basic detection by checking building codes and standards compliance.

New clash detection tech

AI and automation are changing the game:

• Allsite.ai's Service AI 1.0 designs 3D servicing networks from 2D plans, avoiding clashes and meeting local rules.
• Clash Preventor offers real-time detection with a user-friendly interface.
• GENx Design & Technology uses AI for generative design to prevent clashes in big projects.

Working with BIM software

Clash detection tools often work with BIM platforms:

• Autodesk Construction Cloud improves coordination between BIM models and helps teams share data.
• MagiCAD, an add-in for AutoCAD and Revit, focuses on MEP clash detection.
• Fuzor's Live Link feature allows real-time model adjustments to fix clashes quickly.

When picking clash detection software, think about:

• Does it work with your current BIM tools?
• How easy is it to learn and use?
• How good are its reporting and issue tracking features?
• What's the cost and licensing like?

Real-world examples

BIM clash detection has proven its worth in several high-profile construction projects. Let's look at some standout examples:

Empire State Building Redevelopment, New York

The team used BIM clash detection to map the existing structure while preserving key architectural details. This allowed for smooth integration of new systems without compromising the landmark's integrity.

Muscat International Airport, Oman

A general contracting company in Muscat used BIM clash detection for MEP systems. They:

• Created clash-free 3D MEP models in Revit (LOD 400)
• Generated clash detection reports in Navisworks
• Assessed IFC drawings to pre-empt clashes

The results? $7 million saved within 6 months, 100% installation of MEP systems with zero change orders, and fewer field conflicts.

Alder Hey Hospital Project, Liverpool

Using 3D BIM models during pre-construction, the team:

• Identified over 400 clashes before on-site installation
• Saved time
• Cut costs linked to rework and delays

Abu Dhabi International Airport Midfield Terminal Building (MTB)

AECOM used advanced BIM tools for planning and execution. This led to:

• Early identification of thousands of potential conflicts
• Reduced on-site risks
• Better resource allocation throughout the project

What we learned

These examples teach us:

1. Catch clashes early. It makes everything smoother on-site.
2. Talk it out. Regular meetings help solve clashes fast.
3. Be flexible. Projects change, so adapt your approach.
4. Details matter. Even a 1mm tolerance can prevent costly errors.
5. It's worth it. Each clash you find could save up to $17,000.
6. Quality goes up. Clash-free models mean better installations and fewer changes during construction.

In short: BIM clash detection saves money, time, and headaches. It's not just a nice-to-have - it's a must-have for modern construction projects.

Future of BIM clash detection

BIM clash detection is about to get a major upgrade. Here's what's coming:

AI in clash detection

AI is set to shake things up. It'll spot issues faster and more accurately than humans can.

"Imagine feeding the computer the load requirements, room types, etc., and the computer algorithm autonomously designing, routing, and modelling the MEP information." - Bill Allen, EvolveLAB

This isn't sci-fi. "GenMEP" by Building System Planning, Inc. is already doing this.

AI brings:

• Faster analysis of complex models
• Fewer errors
• Better decisions through accurate predictions

Automated clash checks

Say goodbye to manual checks. The future is automatic.

Procore's BIM tool is leading the charge, making models useful throughout the project.

VR and AR in clash detection

VR and AR are set to make clash detection more visual and interactive.

They'll let you:

• Explore designs in 3D
• Review designs in real-time
• Work better with your team

A study found that VR helped experts solve some clashes better than old methods.

"We placed QR codes tied to a detailed BIM model, allowing workers to scan the codes with iPads to identify issues such as missing trim and fire alarms." - Graham Condit, Skanska USA

VR and AR aren't everywhere yet due to cost and training needs. But as prices drop and people get used to them, expect to see more VR and AR on construction sites.

Wrap-up

BIM clash detection is a game-changer in construction. It's all about spotting design conflicts before they become real-world headaches. Here's the lowdown:

• It uses 3D models to find conflicts between building systems
• Catches issues early, saving time and cash
• Gets everyone on the same page - architects, engineers, and builders
• Deals with hard, soft, and time-based clashes

What's Next for Clash Detection?

The future? It's looking pretty slick. New tech is set to turbocharge the process:

• AI will speed up clash spotting and offer fix ideas
• Systems will run clash tests on their own
• VR and AR will let teams dive into designs and fix issues on the fly

Take Procore's BIM tool. It's already pushing towards more automated clash detection. This isn't just a one-off - it's where the whole industry is heading.

What does this mean? We're talking:

• Fewer surprises on-site
• Projects wrapped up faster
• Smarter use of materials
• Builds that match the plan to a T

Bottom line: BIM clash detection is becoming a must-have in construction planning. Jumping on these new tech trends? That's how construction teams will stay ahead of the game.

FAQs

What are the different types of clash detection software?

Clash detection software spots conflicts between building parts in BIM models. Here's a quick look at some popular options:

Navisworks is a top pick for BIM clash detection. Here's what you can do with it:

1. Upload and mix different design models
2. Run clash tests between models
3. Get detailed clash reports in HTML or PDF

Using Navisworks is pretty straightforward:

1. Upload your first design model (like architectural)
2. Load the second model (say, MEP systems)
3. Merge them
4. Run the clash detection scan
5. Check out the clash results, including status and descriptions

But here's the thing: 3D clash detection isn't perfect. As one BIM expert puts it:

"Effective clash detection needs both 2D and 3D coordination. Not everything is modeled perfectly in 3D."

So, for the best results, use a mix of tools and methods in your construction projects.

Related posts

• 2024 Roundup: Best Practices in Estate Management
• BIM QA Checklist: 7 Best Practices
• 5 Best Practices for BIM Data Security
• 4D BIM in Construction: Sequencing & Scheduling